On attrition, alienation, and alternatives: part 2.¹

On attrition, alienation, and alternatives: part 2.¹

On attrition, alienation, and alternatives: part 2.¹

Published on:

18 Jan 2026

3

min read

#notlegaladvice
#sustainability
#law
#notlegaladvice
#notlegaladvice

This article is part of a series. View related content below:

This article is part of a series. View related content below:

This article is part of a series. View related content below:

Antoni Shkraba Studio; https://www.pexels.com/photo/photo-of-colleagues-having-an-argument-6632515/.

We're aware of the attrition rate in the legal profession. In part 1, I offered some suggestions as to why all of us in legal practice should care about this issue.

In this part, let's take a step back and consider why the issue arises in the first place.

--

We could go on and on, but let's cut to the chase. People leave legal practice because of bad bosses.²

And there are bad bosses everywhere.

Because the circumstances which allow someone to rise up the ranks to be in a position of authority...

...do not necessarily equip them with the skills needed to be a good boss.

Actually, let's refine that further. The circumstances which allow someone to rise up the ranks to be in a position of authority...

...DO NOT equip them with the skills needed to be a good boss.

If they end up being a good boss, that's due to other factors that have nothing to do with how they got there in the first place.

--

As an associate, you are judged based on:³
(a) Whether you can prepare drafts which are useable, even if they are not yet the finished product.
(b) Whether you can reach correct legal conclusions by applying the applicable legal principles to the facts at hand.
(c) Whether you are resourceful and can find solutions to random problems that crop up.
(d) Whether your bosses can stand working with you.

The unifying thread that runs through this criteria is: you can thrive as an associate without demonstrating any of the skills that are needed to be a good boss.

And then you become a senior associate, or maybe even a counsel. Perhaps things will change at this point?

Hahaha nope. At this point, your boss is still judging you based on the same criteria.

I accept that there may be some new criteria. For example, you may be expected to start showing the beginnings of a business case. You may be expected to work more independently. But your primary function remains to support your boss. Not to demonstrate the skills needed to be a good boss.

But hold on. At the senior associate / counsel level, you may start working with juniors. Doesn't this mean that you will then pick up the skills needed to be a good boss?

You certainly might. But let me put it this way. If you don't know how to swim, and I throw you into the deep end of the pool, do you magically learn how to swim?⁴

Put another way, while working with juniors certainly puts you in a position where you can pick up the skills, it doesn't necessarily mean you will.

And when you eventually push for promotion to junior partner / associate director...

...does your firm even take into account how well you work with juniors?

If yes, I congratulate your boss and firm for being enlightened. Because that would incentivise you to start picking up, early, the skills to be a good boss.

But - hand on heart - how many firms and bosses are like that?⁵

--

More in part 3.

As usual, #footnotes in comments.

Disclaimer:

The content of this article is intended for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Footnotes:
Footnotes:

¹ Part 1: https://www.linkedin.com/posts/khelvin-xu_footnotes-law-sustainability-activity-7417058414721253376-EK1O/

I know some of you are wondering what took me so long to drop part 2, and whether I ended up chickening out. Sorry! Was on a full-time overseas course. Which is a story for another time.

² Is this the only reason people leave legal practice? Certainly not. But do many leave for this reason? Probably - or at least, enough folks leave for this reason, for it to be worth talking about.

³ There are probably other criteria that I've missed out on, but let's run with this for now. That being said, do leave a comment if you have something to add.

⁴ Not the best analogy, because many senior associates / counsels can and do gradually learn to be good bosses if giving the time and space, whereas you don't get that time and space when you're struggling for dear life in deep waters.

But the point remains that it's not something that happens automatically, and folks need to be supported if they want to grow towards being good bosses.

⁵ I would suggest - not enough.

Never miss a post

Never miss a post
Share It On: